An algorithm for advocacy

Now that Democrats will control Congress, many of us are excited for them to legislate some changes. But which? More to the point, on which of the many issues I support should I press them to act? Here’s a series of questions to help identify what I should prioritize, mostly because of the odds of my effectiveness and the effort’s success. Of course, sometimes I feel so strongly about something that I’ll work for it despite the short-term odds being slim.

The following are initial screening questions. The answer should be yes to all of them, although a more sophisticated approach would rate each on a scale (“How important is it?” instead of “Is it more important than …”).

  • Do I favor it? (Duh.)
  • Is it more important than the potential initiatives – mine and Congress’ – that it will displace?
  • Is it already on Congress’ radar?
  • Will pursuing it not endanger Democrats’ chances in the next election?
  • Will the Supreme Court allow it?
  • Will my intervention make a difference in its chances, even if the effect is small?

The next section would look better as a flowchart.

  1. Is it subject to filibuster in the Senate? According to Wikipedia, these types of bill are not: budget reconciliation, review of administrative regulations, D.C. home rule, declarations of national emergencies, War Powers Resolutions, fast-track trade agreements, and the debt limit.
    1. Yes: Will a combination of 60 Democrats, Republicans, and Independents support it?
      1. Yes: Go to “Will Trump sign it?”.
      2. No: Give up.
    2. No: Will a majority of senators support it?
      1. Yes: Go to “Will Trump sign it?”
      2. No: Give up.
  2. Will Trump sign it?
    1. Yes: Advocate it!
    2. No: Will Congress override the veto?
      1. Yes: Advocate it!
      2. No: Give up.

Leave a Reply