Recently a discussion-group participant stated vaguely that indigenous people see humans as part of a universal order in which they share consciousness in harmony with the nonhuman world. She said this to bolster others’ comments that, when troubled, they feel better outdoors.
The problem with her assertion is manifold: human groups – indigenous or not – have diverse beliefs, as do the individuals within them; depending on a person’s worldview and the context, communing with nonhumans might actually be distressing; and, overall, referencing non-industrialized societies as automatically wiser or less alienated from what’s real is intellectually lazy and reduces their messy humanity to an archetype (a variation on “Noble Savage’). If you want to show respect to others’ beliefs, it behooves you to actually immerse yourself into their worldview; otherwise, you’re simply trying to adorn your own beliefs with unearned legitimacy by leveraging a stereotype. That is, citing the beliefs of “indigenous people” or some other group of Others is too often just a smokescreen for one’s own worldview.
Remember that the founders of the Judeo-Christian tradition, with its tenet that God granted humans dominion over other living things and with its limitation of spiritual agency to humans, were tribal, indigenous people. This is one of many examples showing that being non-industrial doesn’t automatically make people have beliefs that attractively contrast with the human-centric worldview. Of course, many peoples see other organisms as having spirits, but even this doesn’t imply a harmonious relationship with their environment: ancient humans have plausibly led to many extinctions; the ancient Maya in the Yucatan created a variety of environmental problems; some Amazonian groups carefully clear spaces in the forest to mark their domain as separate from the wild; and so forth.
Moreover, people who believe that plants and/or animals can perceive, think, and communicate similarly to humans do not necessarily find comfort in their presence. For example, some South American groups believe that humans and jaguars have a sort of commensurate status, but they generally fear jaguars. In other cases, plants and other animals might be watching and judging human actions – not soothing them. Or they might cry out in distress, as Southern Paiute elders learned by listening to surviving plants in their former homeland. Indeed, it might be that the soothing, restorative experience of “nature” that I and so many other industrialized Westerners feel is facilitated by our background seeing wild plants and animals as categorically different from us.
In short, if a person (ignores every nature documentary ever made and) believes that all organisms are optimized to sing kumbaya in a universal chorus, they should just claim it as their own worldview and give their own reasons for adhering to it.
